Free Matt Kemp!

Mike Scioscia's Tragic Illness

By | April 6, 2008 at 9:55 PM | In Juan Pierre sucks | 6 Comments

I'm not here to complain about Juan Pierre starting over Matt Kemp on Saturday night vs. Jake Peavy.

I'm not here to complain about Juan Pierre starting over Matt Kemp on Sunday afternoon vs. Chris Young, though it's perplexing.

I'd really really like to complain about the fact that Juan Pierre's going to also start on Monday night vs. Dan Haren, even though Pierre went 0-4 today and didn't hit the ball on the ground once, but I'm not going to do that either.

Why? Because we've been over the mediocrity of Juan Pierre many, many, many times, and as he's currently batting .091, I'm pretty sure everyone on the planet knows he's just not all that good, so there's no point in beating it into the ground. And also, Weisman beat me to it and did it much more eloquently than I could have anyway.

No, I'd rather look at the other side: it's common knowledge that Pierre should not be playing, but you might not know just how much Kemp should be playing.

Here's some names for you: Alex Rodriguez, Al Kaline, Albert Pujols, Hank Aaron, Vladimir Guerrero, Miguel Cabrera, Paul Molitor, and Frank Robinson. I feel like I know all those names from somewhere. But where? And what do those names have to do with Matt Kemp? Rany Jazayerli of Baseball Prospectus points out something extremely interesting...

Here at Baseball Prospectus we have long warned of the dangers of overrating the importance of batting average. But still, .342 says something. That’s an impressive average for any hitter. For a 22-year-old hitter? More impressive still. For a 22-year-old right-handed hitter? It’s historic.

[snip]

So for Kemp to hit as well as he did from the right side is most unusual. He became just the tenth right-handed hitter since World War II to hit .320 or better (min: 250 PA) at the age of 22 or less. It’s what you might call a pretty impressive list:
	

	Year  Player             Age   AVG

	1996  Alex Rodriguez      20  .358

	2007  Matt Kemp           22  .342

	1955  Al Kaline           20  .340

	2001  Albert Pujols       21  .329

	1956  Hank Aaron          22  .328

	1998  Vladimir Guerrero   22  .324

	2005  Miguel Cabrera      22  .323

	1979  Paul Molitor        22  .322

	1957  Frank Robinson      21  .322

	1973  Cesar Cedeno        22  .320

	1972  Cesar Cedeno        21  .320
That’s four Hall of Famers, three guys who probably would get voted into the Hall of Fame if they retired today, and a guy (Miguel Cabrera) who’s absolutely on a Hall of Fame trajectory. At the bottom of the list is Cesar Cedeno, who had one of the great “what if” careers in baseball history. And then there’s Kemp.

Hey, no one's calling Matt Kemp a Hall of Famer. But we're not talking about a list of 4 legends and 6 flashes in the pan. Every single one of those guys had excellent careers - even at the low end of this scale, Cesar Cedeno made four All Star teams. Pierre or not, unless our outfield suddenly consists of Carl Crawford, Grady Sizemore, and Ichiro Suzuki (note: it does not) isn't that list of gods a pretty worthwhile reason to just let the kid play every day? I don't want to completely rip off our compadres at Sons of Steve Garvey, but perhaps it's time to update the "Don't Be Stupid" box up there in the corner from "Trade Juan Pierre" to "FREE MATT KEMP!"

Despite some dreadful offensive performances this week, the Dodgers are still 4-2 and tied for first after taking 2 out of 3 in Petco, thanks to some great pitching performances. If we'd like to see the offense perk up, maybe we could, I don't know, play the kid who's shown some possibly historic talent? Maybe?

But I'll keep my word, and this team is in first place at the moment, so this post is for talking up Kemp and not beating down Pierre.

Juan Pierre qualifies for his own list, though not one he’s eager to be seen on. Here’s the list of batters who have made the most outs in a season (outs being defined as at-bats minus hits, plus caught stealing and GIDP) over the last 25 years:
	Year  Player         Outs   R   RBI

	1984  Juan Samuel     531  105   69

	2005  Jose Reyes      528   99   58

	2006  Juan Pierre     521   87   40

	2007  Jimmy Rollins   521  139   94

	2007  Jose Reyes      517  119   57
We include the runs scored and batted in totals to make the point that the other guys on this list at least have the excuse that all the outs they generated did lead to a significant offensive contribution. Pierre? Just to pick a name at random, Edgar Renteria scored as many runs last season as Pierre did in 2006, and drove in 17 more runners, while using up only 346 outs.

Hey - I said I wouldn't dump on him today. That was all Rany!

- Mike Scioscia's tragic illness

- Mike Scioscia's tragic illness

Discussion

6 Comments on "Free Matt Kemp!"

Posted by SoSG Steve Sax, April 7, 2008 9:57 AM

Great post and thanks for the mention. We're with you on this. A couple more of these black hole Pierre starts and we'll get our graphic design team to start making FMK logos.

Posted by Dusto, April 7, 2008 1:51 PM

How long does Torre keep this up before he officially is placed on the "hot seat"?

Could it be possible that the only reason Pierre is starting is so that he gets the opportunity to get a few hits before being traded?

He should have been dumped the day Jones was signed!

Posted by Harold, April 7, 2008 8:59 PM

Oh man did Pierre have another stinker of a game tonight.

As of my writing, two worthless fly-outs and he hit into a double play.

I just don't get why you anyone would deny Matt Kemp the chance to start every day.

Posted by Harold, April 7, 2008 9:01 PM

Oh and by the way it's very early to judge people by statistics, but based on the visual evidence, this is the Andruw Jones of last year, and not the andruw jones of every other year.

Posted by grabarkewitz, April 9, 2008 7:17 AM

One would think that Bison just earned himself starts for the rest of April for last night's effort. My only hope is that Torre is "smarter" than that country hick, Griddle. Besides world peace and the quick, painful death of a certain homeowner in Paradise Valley, AZ, I would hope that Slappy has seen the last of any diamond for the month of April. At least in a Dodger uniform.

Posted by shmolnick, April 10, 2008 7:13 PM

Awesome post, Mike.